Kansas Medicare Supplement Carriers We Compare

Every Medigap Plan G sold in Kansas covers exactly the same benefits, no matter which company sells it. The only real differences between carriers are price, rate stability over time, financial strength, and service. As an independent agency, we're not tied to any single company — we shop your options across every major carrier licensed to sell Medicare Supplement plans in Kansas and help you find the one that fits your budget and long-term needs.

Below is an overview of the carriers we work with most often for Kansas Medicare beneficiaries, along with what makes each one different. Click through to any carrier for plan availability, rate context, and what to know before you enroll.

Medicare Supplement Carrier Comparison

Carrier Plans Offered in Kansas Known For Learn More
Mutual of Omaha Plan A, F, G, High-Deductible G, N A+ (Superior) AM Best rating, low complaint rates, one of the largest household discounts available Mutual of Omaha in Kansas
UnitedHealthcare (AARP) Wide range of plan letters, including G and N Largest Medigap carrier nationally, AARP-branded plans, broad plan letter availability UnitedHealthcare in Kansas
HealthSpring (formerly Cigna) Plan G, N Former Cigna Medicare Supplement book, now operating under the HealthSpring brand following its 2025 sale to HCSC HealthSpring in Kansas
Aetna Plan G, N Backed by CVS Health, competitive underwriting in many age bands Aetna in Kansas
Humana Plan A, F, G, N Broad plan selection and nationwide recognition, though often priced above other carriers for Plan G/N Humana in Kansas
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas Plan G, N, and others Kansas-based carrier with long-standing name recognition statewide BCBS Kansas
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas City Plan G, N, and others Strong recognition in the Kansas City metro, useful for border-county residents BCBS Kansas City
Wellabe Plan G, N Midwest-focused Medicare Supplement carrier Wellabe in Kansas
Insurance Company of North America Plan F, G, High-Deductible G, N A Chubb company with an A++ (Superior) AM Best rating — the highest tier available; new carrier name replacing ACE Medicare Supplement INA in Kansas
Old Surety Life Plan F, G (issue-age rated) Oklahoma-based carrier writing in Kansas since the early Medigap market; issue-age rating can mean slower long-term increases Old Surety Life in Kansas

Plan availability, pricing, and underwriting can change. Call 913-395-9898 for current Kansas availability and rates for any carrier above.

Considering Medicare Advantage Instead?

Devoted Health and Wellcare don't sell Medicare Supplement plans in Kansas — both are Medicare Advantage carriers. If you're weighing Medigap against a Medicare Advantage plan, we also help Kansas beneficiaries compare Devoted's and Wellcare's Advantage plans where available.

Compare Devoted Medicare Advantage in Kansas → Compare Wellcare Medicare Advantage in Kansas →

Don't See Your Carrier Above?

The carriers listed on this page are the ones we compare most often for Kansas Medicare beneficiaries, but they're not the only companies we work with. As an independent agency, we have access to additional Medicare Supplement carriers beyond this list — if you have a specific company in mind, or an existing policy you're thinking about switching from, just ask.

Ask About a Specific Carrier →

Why the Carrier You Choose Still Matters

Since Medigap benefits are federally standardized, it's tempting to assume the carrier is irrelevant. In practice, three things vary a lot by company:

  • Rate history. Some carriers have a track record of smaller, more predictable annual increases than others.
  • Underwriting approach. If you're switching plans outside your Open Enrollment or Guaranteed Issue window, underwriting standards differ carrier to carrier — this can be the difference between an approval and a decline.
  • Discounts. Household discounts, payment-method discounts, and multi-policy discounts vary and can meaningfully change your effective premium.

This is exactly the kind of comparison an independent broker is built for — we're not incentivized to steer you toward one company over another.

Get a Free Comparison Across These Carriers

No obligation. Local Kansas experts. One phone call.

Request a Quote

Or call 913-395-9898

Carrier Comparison FAQs

Does it matter which carrier I pick for Plan G in Kansas?

The benefits are identical no matter the carrier — a Plan G is a Plan G. What differs is price, rate-increase history, underwriting, and discounts. That's why comparing carriers, not just picking a familiar name, is worth doing.

Is Cigna still selling Medicare Supplement plans?

Cigna sold its Medicare Supplement business to Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC) in 2025. Former Cigna Medigap policies are now serviced under the HealthSpring brand. Existing coverage isn't affected, but new applications are no longer taken under the Cigna name.

Can I switch Medigap carriers if I already have a policy?

Yes, but outside your initial 6-month Open Enrollment Period or a Guaranteed Issue situation, you'll typically go through medical underwriting with the new carrier. We can walk through whether switching makes sense in your situation.

Do you represent every Medicare Supplement carrier in Kansas?

We represent a broad panel of the carriers most Kansas seniors consider, listed above. If a carrier you're interested in isn't listed, ask us — we may still have access or can point you in the right direction.